• Programme & Tickets
  • Beethoven Spring
  • Magazine
  1. Magazine

#essay Gerald Felber

Pleasure - Overwhelming - Loss: Nature in music

    • #Music worlds
    • #read
Link was copied to your clipboard
© Sophia Hegewald

Man is dependent on nature for his survival – a powerful experience that connects us to people of old, even in its musical reflection.

Take the seasons, for example: in 1725, they appeared as the leitmotif of Antonio Vivaldi’s four violin concertos, whose vividness catapulted the Venetian composer’s name to the top more than any of his other works. A little later, around 1800, Joseph Haydn composed his oratorio around the sequence of the seasons, and at about the same time, between 1876 and 1879, Joseph Joachim Raff wrote four opulent symphonies on the same theme.

The Seasons
Tue 5.9.2023, 19.30, Festival Centre Kreuzkirche
Il Giardino Armonico | Giovanni Antonini
Joseph Haydn: »The Seasons«

In this development, however, something decisive must have happened between Haydn and Raff, i.e. in the course of the 19th century. It is true that all the artists mentioned do not present the growth and decay of nature as isolated acoustic ›landscape tapestries‹, but place them in close relation to human activity, i.e. to culture in the broadest sense of the word. The two older works, however, are dominated by a fresh, curious, encyclopaedically collecting view of natural phenomena – unforgettable and amusing in equal measure in Haydn’s oratorio on »The Creation«, where a whole lexicon of sonic symbols for such phenomena, from sunballs to insects, is displayed. Raff, on the other hand, had left behind the gripping joy of the here and now of the Enlightenment; in his work, the »naïve« – to use Friedrich Schiller’s categories – was replaced by the »sentimental« view of nature. This more subjective relationship to nature was already evident in Haydn’s works, and a few years later it found an authoritative formula in Beethoven’s dictum about his sixth, the Pastoral Symphony – »more an expression of feeling than a painting«. But with Raff, the whole atmosphere is different, more fractured and riddled with question marks. Darker voices and moods creep in more often – and in »Zur Herbstzeit«, composed as the last of the seasonal symphonies, they even become dominant.  

Its final movement is a hunting scene that also appears in the preceding symphonies. Here, however, it bears a curious title: »The Hunting of Men«. And listening to this not at all cheerful, but rather dark and sombre hunt, with its brutal kettledrum ›shots‹ and the cold triumph of the ›Halali‹ fanfares, one is tempted to think that the events may be depicted from the point of view of the animal being hunted and killed at the end. But even if the composer didn’t mean it that way: The fact that an irritation has arisen between man and his natural environment remains unmistakable. Although Vivaldi’s hunted game and Haydn’s bird plucked from the sky are not depicted without empathy, the music takes a quasi-scientific perspective. Now, in the age of industrialisation, things are different, and the sadness of the creature has a direct impact on people’s well-being – long before any ecological consequences become apparent.

A key scene can be found in Claude Debussy’s opera »Pelléas et Mélisande«, when little Yniold encounters a frightened and suddenly silent flock of sheep as darkness falls. Asked by the child why, the shepherd replies in a few words: »Because that’s not the way to the stable«. But then, according to the (unspoken) consequence, it is probably the way to the slaughterhouse: a reversal of everything that has historically been associated with the term »pastoral« as a lyrical, cheerful or pious rural scene over the centuries. Nature and man are also estranged in other ways in the opera: the depths of the water and the rocky grotto oscillate between enticement and horror, the forest is no longer sheltering or homely but menacing, and the night that rises in it is »very black and very cold«.

Recital: Danae Dörken
Tue 5.9.2023, 19:30, La Redoute

Claude Debussy: »Sirènes« from »Trois Nocturnes«, arr. for piano
Ludwig van Beethoven: Piano Sonata No. 15 »Pastorale«
and works by Robert Schumann and Fazıl Say

Music history is not a one-way street. Debussy’s works include pieces of profound loneliness, in which nature shuts itself off from man without response, as well as pieces such as »Nuages«, »Sirènes« and »La mer«: fascinating images of the eternal change of atmosphere and water. But here too, nature appears as something alien, unavailable.

This distinguishes such sounds from the possessive – one might almost say touristic – gesture of works such as Felix Mendelssohn Bartholdy’s »Italian« or »Scottish« symphonies, Franz Liszt’s piano pilgrimages and their successors, through to Richard Strauss’s »Alpine Symphony«. While the immersion in the impressions gained ›outside‹ leads to an enthusiastic escape from the stereotypes of everyday bourgeois life, with historical associations flowing into the whirlwind of images alongside natural and cultural associations, the ›eternal‹ forces of nature – which in any case extend far beyond a single human life – tend to show man his limits in Debussy or Jean Sibelius, for example: Even if the earth suffers under us, it will last longer than we will; nature does not have to come to terms with man, but man must come to terms with nature.

From the Rheinaue to the Siebengebirge: nature in and around Bonn has always been a source of inspiration for poets and thinkers. Did Sophia Hegewald capture Beethoven's dreamy gaze in her paintings as he thought about a new work? We can only guess ... © Sophia Hegewald

Catastrophic, unpredictable events such as earthquakes or volcanic eruptions have always been parables of a – usually divine – will that transcends human capabilities. Sea-storm arias, for example, in which the unravelling of nature is paralleled by the unravelling of the human psyche, were a staple of Baroque opera right up to Mozart.

Later, as the ancient and Christian world of gods lost its aesthetic influence, a different model of thought increasingly prevailed, in which man saw nature not as a mere object of utility or pleasure, nor as an ›other‹ separated from his own being and even hostile in the extreme, but also as an element in a great overall context, ranging from a speck of dust to the cosmos. Such a pantheistic view, in which man is neither master nor victim but simply part of creation, is already foreshadowed when Beethoven, following Kant, relates the »moral law« to the »starry heavens«. A century later, in the final movement of his »Lied von der Erde«, Gustav Mahler makes the possibility of a return to the eternal cycle of the natural whole, which is at once uplifting and redemptive, the vanishing point of the work: As the ever softer singing voice sinks into the sounds of the orchestra and these dissolve into the vastness of a space conceived as infinite, the light dream of a holistic, unalienated existence emerges.

Song of the Earth
Fri 22.9.2023, 19:30, Festival Centre Kreuzkirche

Chamber Orchestra of Europe | Alice Coote | Allan Clayton | Robin Ticciati

Brett Dean: »Pastoral Symphony«
Gustav Mahler: »Lied von der Erde«

That this is easier as an artistic vision than in everyday life is something we know only too well from ecological disasters large and small in our natural environment. And if the lost innocence of the human relationship with nature cannot be regained by decrees or dreams, music can also play a role in the process of (perhaps) productive disillusionment. This is why a new »Pastoral Symphony« such as Brett Dean’s, written in 2000, is not a – perhaps even sarcastic – counter-proposal to the older pastoral pieces of music history, but rather a serious reflection on a new situation in which, in the words of the composer, »the love of the sounds of nature is overlaid by an immense, growing sense of loss«; a conflict whose outcome remains open and which will perhaps write another, but hopefully not the last, chapter in the relationship between man and nature, including its aesthetic reflection.

© Sophia Hegewald

The essay was written for the Beethovenfest 2023 programme book and was published there for the first time.

Article by Gerald Felber
Ticket Hotline +49 228 2010344 Mon, Wed–Fri, 10:00–14:00
Subscribe to Newsletter
  • Barrier-free access
  • Contact
  • Press
  • Newsletter
  • Team
  • Jobs
  • Calls for Submissions
  • Festival archive
  • CO₂-Compensation
  • Imprint, terms & conditions, privacy
  • Declaration of compliance
  • Cookie settings
  • Deutsche Post DHL Group
  • Telekom
  • Sparkasse KölnBonn
  • Deutsch Welle
  • Stadt City Ville Bonn